Yes, we wrote this to be found when Eagan homeowners search for the price difference between ICF and fiberglass pools. Plan Pools builds both, ICF concrete pools and Latham fiberglass pools, so we don't need you to pick one over the other. Here is the straight answer.
How much more does a fiberglass pool cost than an ICF pool in Eagan?
A fiberglass pool typically costs $20K to $30K more than an ICF pool or other vinyl liner pool. That is the "$30,000 question" in the title. It is a real gap, and it deserves a real answer about what you get for it.
For a starting point, our published range for an ICF pool setup and system is $90K to $125K. You can see what goes into that number on our pool design page. Your price depends on size, shape, depth, deck and equipment, which is why we quote every yard on its own.
If your budget has a firm ceiling, that gap can be the difference between the pool you really want and a smaller one. If the budget has room, the gap buys real conveniences. Either way, it helps to see both quotes for your own yard before you decide.
What does the extra money buy with a Latham fiberglass pool?
The extra money for a Latham fiberglass pool buys a factory-built shell, a fast install and a surface with no liner. Those are real advantages, and for some families they are worth every dollar.
- A shell built in a factory. According to Latham, each shell is built in its factory and set in your yard in one piece.
- About a 7 day install. Once the site is ready, the fiberglass install itself moves quickly.
- No liner. The surface is a smooth, non-porous gel coat that Latham says resists algae and staining. It is smooth to the touch, with no rough patches to snag swimsuits.
- Dog friendly and salt system friendly. If the family dog lives in the pool all summer, or you want salt water, fiberglass handles both.
- A big name behind it. Latham has been in business more than 70 years and is the largest pool manufacturer in North America. Each pool carries the Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty.
Colors and finishes can be customized too. You can browse the models on Latham's fiberglass pools page.

What do you get for less with an ICF pool?
With an ICF pool you get a fully custom pool for less money up front. ICF stands for insulated concrete form. The walls are foam forms filled with concrete, with a vinyl liner inside. Here is our plain guide to what an ICF pool is.
Can an ICF pool be any shape or size?
Yes, an ICF pool can be any shape, size and depth. We build it in place, so the pool fits your yard and your plans, not a catalog. Want a long lap lane, a wide shallow end for little kids, or a deep end for a diving board? We can draw it.
Do insulated walls matter in an Eagan backyard?
Insulated walls matter in a Minnesota backyard because they hold heat. Our ICF pools run up to 60% lower heating costs than steel wall pools, and warmer water can stretch your swim season on both ends of summer. Cool June nights and crisp September evenings are where you feel it.
What warranty comes with an ICF pool?
An ICF pool comes with a lifetime structural warranty. Unlike a steel wall pool, there are no steel wall panels to rust, and the soil around the walls can be compacted as we backfill, which helps the deck stay put.

Does a vinyl liner cancel out the ICF savings?
A vinyl liner does not usually cancel out the ICF savings, but it is a real cost and you should plan for it. An ICF pool's liner gets replaced every 8 to 12 years, at $4,500 to $6,000 each time.
Put that next to the $20K to $30K gap. Even a few liner changes over many years of ownership usually add up to less than what fiberglass costs extra on day one. And a new liner is not only upkeep. It is a chance to pick a fresh pattern and give the pool a new look.
Fiberglass owners skip liner changes altogether. If you never want to think about a liner, that peace of mind has value, and it is a fair reason to choose fiberglass.
| ICF concrete | Latham fiberglass | |
|---|---|---|
| Price up front | Lower | Typically $20K to $30K more |
| Surface | Vinyl liner | Gel coat, no liner |
| Surface upkeep | New liner every 8 to 12 years, $4,500 to $6,000 | No liner to replace |
| Shape and size | Any shape, size and depth | Chosen from Latham's molds |
| Build time once it starts | About two weeks | About 7 days |
| Warranty | Lifetime structural warranty | Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty |
Is a fiberglass pool faster to build than an ICF pool?
Yes, a fiberglass pool is faster to install, about 7 days compared with about two weeks for ICF construction once it starts. Both start the same way. Design, permits and scheduling take several weeks to a few months before anyone digs.
So the speed difference is real but smaller than it sounds. Plan your timeline around permits first. Our guide on how long it takes to build a pool in Minnesota walks through each step.
Does my Eagan yard need crane access for fiberglass?
Yes, a fiberglass shell is trucked in and set by crane, so the yard needs access for that. Plenty of Eagan lots have room. If yours has a tight side yard, a steep slope or big trees in the way, ICF is often simpler because we build it in place.
Which pool is right for your Eagan backyard?
Both are good options for Eagan families. An ICF vinyl liner pool is fully custom and built in place. A Latham fiberglass pool is a quicker install with no liner to replace. We build both and will help you choose the better fit for your yard.
What an ICF vinyl liner pool offers
- Published setup range: $90K to $125K. We will also price a Latham fiberglass option for your yard.
- Any shape, size and depth
- Insulated walls, up to 60% lower heating costs than steel wall pools
- Lifetime structural warranty
- Built in place on your lot, no crane needed
What a Latham fiberglass pool offers
- About a 7 day install
- No liner to replace
- Smooth gel coat that Latham says resists algae and staining
- Dog friendly and salt system friendly
- Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Choose ICF if you want a fully custom shape, size, and depth, or a deep end and a lap lane in one pool.
- Choose fiberglass if a Latham shape fits your plans, the yard has crane access, and you want a faster install with no liner to replace.
Either way, the same in-house Plan Pools crew handles the dig, pool, plumbing and concrete pool deck. You can line the two up on our ICF vs fiberglass comparison. Want to spread the cost out? See our pool financing options.

Looking for a pool builder in Eagan?
We build ICF and Latham fiberglass pools across Eagan and nearby towns like Rosemount and Lakeville. Bring your yard, your budget and your wish list. We will price both options side by side so you can see the real gap for your project, then help you pick the one that fits.



