Yes, we wrote this to be found when Eden Prairie homeowners search for which pool holds up best through a Minnesota winter. Plan Pools builds ICF pools and installs Latham fiberglass pools, so we have no reason to talk you into one or the other. Here is the straight answer.
What does a Minnesota winter do to an inground pool?
A Minnesota winter puts an inground pool through deep cold, frozen ground and a wet spring thaw. Eden Prairie gets all of it. The soil around the pool freezes, thaws, gets soaked by snowmelt and freezes again. A good pool build plans for that from the first day of the dig.
How a pool and deck look after a few winters comes down to the wall, the soil around it and a proper winter closing. This post covers the first two. Our Minnesota pool closing guide covers the third.
How does an ICF pool wall handle frost and freeze-thaw?
An ICF pool wall handles frost well because it is a solid, insulated concrete wall built in place. ICF stands for insulated concrete forms. The forms are foam blocks filled with concrete, with a vinyl liner on the inside. There are no steel walls to rust, and the foam on both sides wraps the concrete core.
Plan Pools backs its ICF pools with a lifetime structural warranty. If you're weighing ICF against a steel wall pool, our guide to how Minnesota's freeze-thaw cycle affects ICF and steel wall pools goes deeper. For the basics of the build, see what an ICF pool is.
Does an insulated wall help in spring and fall too?
Yes. Insulated walls hold heat, so the water stays comfortable longer on cool nights and the season can run longer at both ends. Plan Pools publishes up to 60% lower heating costs for ICF pools than steel wall pools.
Why does compacted backfill matter for an Eden Prairie pool deck?
Compacted backfill matters because the soil right around the pool is what holds up the deck. When a pool is dug, there is a gap between the pool wall and the undisturbed ground. That gap gets filled back in. With an ICF wall, our crew can compact that soil as it goes back in, so it ends up firm instead of loose.
Firm soil helps the concrete pool deck stay put. Soil that isn't compacted can settle over time, especially after a wet spring, and the deck on top can move with it. Compacting at the start is one of the simplest ways to keep the deck level and the edges tight for the long run.

Does it help that one crew does the dig, pool and deck?
Yes. Our in-house crew handles the dig, the pool, the plumbing and the concrete deck. The people who compact the backfill are the same people who pour the deck on top of it, so nothing gets lost in a handoff between companies.

Can a fiberglass pool handle Minnesota winters?
Yes. Latham says its fiberglass pools are suitable for any climate, and that includes ours. Latham has been in business for more than 70 years and says it is the largest pool manufacturer in North America. According to Latham, each shell is built in its factory and set in one piece, with a smooth, non-porous gel coat that resists algae and staining.
Latham also says its fiberglass pools never need resurfacing, and there is no liner to replace. Latham pools carry the Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty, and you can read the details on Latham's warranty page.
Like any pool in Minnesota, a fiberglass pool still needs a proper closing each fall and a careful install. The shell is trucked in and set by crane, so your yard needs access for that. Once the site is ready, the install takes about 7 days.

What should you ask a pool builder about Minnesota winters?
Whichever pool you lean toward, ask the builder a few plain questions before you sign. Good answers tell you the crew has built through real Minnesota winters.
- How will the soil around the pool be backfilled, and will it be compacted?
- Who pours the deck, and is it the same crew that built the pool?
- What does the warranty cover, and who do I call if something comes up?
- How do you close the pool each fall, and do you offer that service?
- Does my yard have the access this pool needs?
What an ICF vinyl liner pool offers
- Soil around the wall can be compacted, which helps the deck stay put
- Insulated walls hold heat, so the season can run longer
- No steel walls to rust
- Lifetime structural warranty
- Any shape, size and depth, fully custom
What a Latham fiberglass pool offers
- Latham says its pools are suitable for any climate
- No liner, and Latham says they never need resurfacing
- About a 7 day install
- Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty
- Dog friendly and salt system friendly
Which pool is right for your Eden Prairie yard?
ICF is usually the better fit if you want a pool built to your own shape and depth, if a solid deck that stays put is high on your list, if you want insulated walls that hold heat into the fall, or if you'd like to spend less up front. A Latham fiberglass pool typically runs $20K to $30K more than an ICF or other vinyl liner pool.
Latham fiberglass is a great choice if a Latham model fits your yard, if you'd rather never think about a liner, if you have dogs that swim, or if a fast install matters and your yard has crane access.
Eden Prairie lots range from wooded and sloped to open and flat, and the city has its own rules on where a pool can go. Our post on minimum lot size for a pool in Eden Prairie is a good first read. Then compare both options on our concrete pools page and our fiberglass pools page.
Looking for a pool builder in Eden Prairie?
Plan Pools builds ICF pools and installs Latham fiberglass pools in Eden Prairie, Minnetonka, Chaska and across the Twin Cities. We'll walk your yard, talk through how each pool handles our winters, and give you a straight recommendation.



