ICF Liner or Fiberglass Gel Coat? Caring for a Pool Surface in Lakeville

An ICF pool gets a new vinyl liner every 8 to 12 years, which also refreshes the look. Latham says its gel coat never needs resurfacing. Here is how to weigh the two.

A long backyard pool with a concrete deck, colorful lounge chairs and a white rock garden behind a large Lakeville home

Yes, we wrote this to be found when Lakeville homeowners search for how pool surfaces hold up over the years. Plan Pools builds both ICF concrete pools and Latham fiberglass pools, so we have no reason to talk you out of either one. Here is the straight answer.

What is the surface of an ICF pool made of?

The surface of an ICF pool is a vinyl liner set inside insulated concrete walls. ICF stands for insulated concrete form. We stack foam forms, fill them with concrete, and the liner goes in last, as the part you see and touch. Our guide to what an ICF pool is has the full picture.

That split matters for long-term care. The concrete walls are the structure, and they carry a lifetime structural warranty. The liner is the finish. When the finish wears, you change the finish, and the walls stay right where they are.

ICF wallInsulated, built in placeWaterSoilFoamConcreteFoamLinerFiberglass shellOne piece, factory builtWaterSoilBackfillGel coat shell
Illustration. How an ICF wall is built up, next to a one-piece fiberglass shell.

How often does an ICF pool liner need to be replaced?

An ICF pool liner needs to be replaced every 8 to 12 years. A replacement runs $4,500 to $6,000. That is the honest number, and we put it in front of every family before they sign.

Where your pool lands in that range depends on how it gets used and cared for. Our guides on winterizing a pool in Minnesota and pool liner choices cover the basics of caring for a liner.

Can a new liner change the look of my pool?

Yes, a new liner changes the look of your pool. A liner change is the one moment in a pool's life when you can pick a new pattern and color without touching the structure. The pool you fell for when the kids were small can look different by the time they are in high school.

Does the rest of the pool change when the liner does?

No, the walls, shape and deck stay the same when the liner changes. You keep the custom shape you designed and the concrete pool deck around it. Only the finish inside is new.

Finished Plan Pools ICF pool and patio in Lakeville
An ICF pool by Plan Pools in Lakeville.

Does a fiberglass pool ever need resurfacing?

According to Latham, its fiberglass pools never need resurfacing. The shell is built in Latham's factory and set in one piece, with a smooth, non-porous gel coat that Latham says resists algae and staining.

That gel coat is a real strength. It is smooth to the touch, with no rough patches to snag swimsuits, and there is no liner to replace. Latham offers 12 Crystite gel coat colors, which you can see on Latham's pool colors page. Every pool carries the Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty.

The trade-off is that the color you pick on day one is the color you live with. That suits a lot of families just fine. If you like the idea of a new look later, a liner gives you that option.

A Latham Claremont fiberglass pool with a sapphire blue gel coat
A Latham fiberglass pool. Photo: Latham.

Which costs less over time, a liner or a gel coat?

A liner usually costs less over time, because an ICF pool costs much less up front. A Latham fiberglass pool typically costs $20K to $30K more than an ICF or other vinyl liner pool. Liner changes at $4,500 to $6,000 every 8 to 12 years take a long time to add up to that gap.

Fiberglass buys you something for that money, though. No liner changes to schedule, and a surface Latham says never needs resurfacing. Some Lakeville families would rather pay once and be done. Others would rather keep the savings and refresh the pool down the road. Both are good choices.

ICF concreteFully custom shapeUp frontNew linerNew linerLiner replaced every 8 to 12 years$4,500 to $6,000 each timeA new liner also refreshes the lookLatham fiberglassNo liner to replaceUp frontNo liner swapsTypically $20K to $30K morethan an ICF or vinyl liner poolThe extra up front
Illustration. ICF costs less up front with a liner change every 8 to 12 years, while fiberglass costs more up front with no liner.

Does the surface choice change what else you get?

Yes, the surface choice comes with the rest of the pool type. Picking a liner means picking ICF, and picking a gel coat means picking fiberglass. Each brings its own package.

What comes with an ICF pool besides the liner?

  • Any shape, size and depth. We build it in place, so it fits your yard, not a mold.
  • Insulated walls. Up to 60% lower heating costs than steel wall pools, and warm water that holds into the shoulder seasons.
  • Compacted backfill. The soil around the walls can be compacted, which helps the deck stay put.
  • Salt ready. We install Pentair salt chlorination systems on most of our ICF pools.

What comes with a fiberglass pool besides the gel coat?

  • About a 7 day install once the site is ready.
  • Shapes from Latham's molds, many with tanning ledges, swim-up seating, built-in spas and auto cover ready designs. See Latham's pool shapes.
  • Dog friendly and salt system friendly.
  • Crane delivery. The shell is trucked in and set by crane, so the yard needs access for that.

Can both pool surfaces run a salt system?

Yes, both pool surfaces can run a salt system. We install Pentair salt chlorination systems on most of our ICF pools, and Latham fiberglass pools are salt system friendly. Our post on salt water vs chlorine pools in Minnesota covers how the two compare.

What should Lakeville families ask before picking a pool surface?

Lakeville families should ask a few plain questions before picking a pool surface. Your answers usually point to one option pretty fast.

  • How long do we plan to stay in this house? If you expect to be here for many years, a liner change or two is part of the plan with ICF. Price that in next to the higher cost of fiberglass up front.
  • Will we want a new look someday? If you like to update things, a liner lets you restyle the pool without rebuilding it. If you would rather set it and forget it, a gel coat suits you.
  • Does a Latham shape fit our yard? If one of the molds fits your space and your plans, fiberglass is on the table. If you want something only you have, ICF is the way.
  • Can a crane reach the backyard? A fiberglass shell is set by crane. An ICF pool is built in place, so tight yards are rarely a problem.
  • Who will swim in it most? Dogs, little kids, lap swimmers and teens with a diving board all shape the choice. Tell us who is in the water and we can point you the right way.

Which pool surface is right for your Lakeville backyard?

Both are good surfaces for Lakeville families. An ICF vinyl liner pool is fully custom, and a new liner every 8 to 12 years can refresh the look. A Latham fiberglass pool is the more hands-off surface: Latham says the gel coat never needs resurfacing. We build both and will help you choose the better fit for your yard.

What an ICF vinyl liner pool offers

  • Published ICF setup range: $90K to $125K
  • A new liner every 8 to 12 years refreshes the whole look
  • Any shape, size and depth
  • Lifetime structural warranty on the walls
  • Insulated walls, up to 60% lower heating costs than steel wall pools

What a Latham fiberglass pool offers

  • No liner to replace
  • Latham says its pools never need resurfacing
  • Smooth gel coat that resists algae and staining, per Latham
  • About a 7 day install
  • Latham Limited Lifetime Warranty

You can compare the two side by side on our ICF vs fiberglass comparison.

Finished Plan Pools backyard pool and patio with a pergola
A Plan Pools backyard, with the pool, deck and patio built by one crew.

Looking for a pool builder in Lakeville?

We build ICF and Latham fiberglass pools across Lakeville, Prior Lake and Farmington. Our in-house crew handles the dig, pool, plumbing and concrete deck, so one team owns the whole job. Tell us how you want the pool to look on day one and years down the road, and we will show you which option gets you there.

Get your backyard oasis

Finally build the backyard your family deserves.

Few things bring family and friends together like an evening at the pool. Book a no-pressure consultation and finally spend summer at home. Or text Joe a few photos of your yard.