You've made the exciting decision to build a backyard swimming pool, and now you're facing a critical question: which insurance company will provide the best coverage and value for your Minnesota home with a pool?
Not all insurance companies treat pool owners equally. Some insurers refuse to cover homes with pools altogether. Others charge excessive premiums or provide inadequate liability limits. And a few specialize in pool properties and offer excellent coverage at competitive rates.
Choosing the right insurance provider can save you hundreds or even thousands of dollars annually while ensuring you're properly protected against the significant liability risks pool ownership creates. But making the wrong choice could leave you underinsured, overpaying, or worse—unable to find coverage at all.
This comprehensive guide identifies the best insurance providers for Minnesota pool owners, explains what makes them stand out, and provides a strategic framework for finding the optimal coverage for your specific situation.
What Makes an Insurance Provider "Best" for Pool Owners?
Before diving into specific companies, let's establish the criteria that determine which insurers excel at covering pool properties:
1. Willingness to Insure Pools
The baseline requirement: Some major insurers simply won't cover homes with pools, or they impose such restrictive requirements that coverage becomes impractical.
What excellent insurers offer:
- Clear, published guidelines for pool coverage
- Reasonable safety requirements (not excessive or impractical)
- Experience underwriting pool properties
- No arbitrary restrictions on pool types or features
2. Adequate Liability Limits
Standard vs. pool-appropriate coverage:
- Poor providers: Cap liability at $100,000-$300,000 with expensive increases for higher limits
- Good providers: Offer $500,000-$1,000,000 liability limits at reasonable costs
- Excellent providers: Provide umbrella policies up to $5 million+ with competitive pricing
3. Competitive Pricing for Pool Properties
Premium considerations:
- Fair premium increases for pool addition (10-20% rather than 30-40%+)
- Meaningful discounts for safety features
- Multi-policy bundling discounts
- Loyalty rewards for long-term customers
4. Claims Handling Reputation
When something goes wrong:
- Fast, fair claim processing
- Experienced adjusters who understand pool-related claims
- Reasonable settlement offers without excessive disputes
- Good communication throughout claims process
- Financial strength to pay large liability claims
5. Customer Service Quality
Day-to-day experience:
- Knowledgeable agents who understand pool insurance complexities
- Responsive customer service
- Easy policy management (online, mobile apps)
- Proactive communication about coverage needs
- Helpful guidance on safety and risk reduction
6. Financial Strength
Ability to pay claims:
- Strong financial ratings from independent agencies (A.M. Best, Standard & Poor's, Moody's)
- Adequate reserves for catastrophic claims
- History of stability and reliability
7. Minnesota Market Experience
Regional expertise:
- Understanding of Minnesota's unique risks (freeze-thaw, attractive nuisance laws, etc.)
- Experience with Minnesota pool properties
- Local agents and adjusters
- Competitive rates for Minnesota market
Top Insurance Providers for Minnesota Pool Owners
Based on extensive research, customer feedback, and industry analysis, here are the insurance companies that consistently excel at covering Minnesota homes with pools:
Tier 1: Excellent Pool Coverage (Highest Recommended)
These insurers provide superior coverage, competitive pricing, and outstanding service for pool owners:
1. State Farm
Overall Rating: ★★★★★ (Excellent)
Why State Farm excels for pool owners:
Coverage strengths:
- Readily insures homes with pools in Minnesota
- Offers liability limits up to $500,000 on homeowner's policies
- Competitively priced umbrella policies ($1M-$5M)
- Reasonable premium increases for pool addition (typically 10-18%)
- Meaningful safety feature discounts (fencing, covers, alarms)
Claims reputation:
- Generally positive claims experience
- Experienced adjusters handle pool-related claims
- Reasonably fast claim processing
- Good communication during claims
Customer service:
- Large network of local agents throughout Minnesota
- Accessible customer service with 24/7 availability
- User-friendly mobile app and online account management
- Proactive policy reviews and coverage updates
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A++
- One of the largest insurers in the U.S. with excellent financial reserves
- Strong ability to pay large liability claims
Pricing:
- Competitive rates, especially with multi-policy discounts
- Good bundling discounts (auto + home + umbrella)
- Loyalty discounts for long-term customers
Considerations:
- Coverage and pricing can vary significantly by location and agent
- Some customers report difficulty reaching agents during busy periods
- Claims experience varies by local claim office
Best for:
- Families wanting established, reliable coverage
- Homeowners who value local agent relationships
- Bundling home and auto insurance
- Those seeking umbrella coverage through same provider
Minnesota presence: Extensive network with hundreds of agents throughout Twin Cities and Greater Minnesota
Contact: Find local State Farm agents at statefarm.com or call 800-STATE-FARM
2. Travelers Insurance
Overall Rating: ★★★★★ (Excellent)
Why Travelers excels for pool owners:
Coverage strengths:
- Actively seeks pool properties with quality risk characteristics
- Offers enhanced liability limits ($500,000-$1,000,000 on homeowner's policy)
- Excellent umbrella policy options up to $10 million
- Reasonable safety requirements
- Strong discounts for superior safety features
Claims reputation:
- Excellent claims handling reputation
- Specialized adjusters with pool claim experience
- Fair, prompt settlements
- Transparency throughout claims process
Customer service:
- Professional, knowledgeable agents
- Excellent online and mobile tools
- Proactive risk management guidance
- Responsive customer support
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A++
- S&P Rating: AA
- One of the oldest, most financially stable insurers
Pricing:
- Premium pricing (not the cheapest, but competitive for coverage provided)
- Excellent multi-policy discounts
- Rewards program for claim-free years
Unique advantages:
- "IntelliDrive" program can save up to 30% on auto insurance (which improves bundling savings)
- Superior coverage options (extended replacement cost, etc.)
- Excellent identity theft and cyber protection endorsements
Considerations:
- May not be the cheapest option
- More selective in underwriting (stricter standards can mean more requirements)
- Not available through all agent channels
Best for:
- Homeowners prioritizing quality over lowest price
- Properties with superior safety features and maintenance
- Those wanting comprehensive, superior coverage
- Bundling multiple policies for maximum discounts
Minnesota presence: Available through independent agents throughout Minnesota
Contact: Find Travelers coverage through independent insurance agents or travelers.com
3. Auto-Owners Insurance
Overall Rating: ★★★★½ (Excellent)
Why Auto-Owners excels for pool owners:
Coverage strengths:
- Excellent reputation for insuring pool properties
- High liability limits available at competitive prices
- Comprehensive umbrella policy options
- Reasonable pool-related premium increases (12-20%)
- Good safety feature discounts
Claims reputation:
- Outstanding claims reputation
- Consistently high customer satisfaction ratings
- Fair, efficient claim processing
- Local claim adjusters with Minnesota experience
Customer service:
- Sold through independent agents who often provide excellent personalized service
- Good online account management
- Responsive customer support
- Proactive policy reviews
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A++
- Strong financial reserves
- Excellent long-term stability
Pricing:
- Very competitive rates, especially for well-maintained properties
- Excellent bundling discounts
- Good loyalty rewards
- Often beats "big name" competitors on price while providing equal or better coverage
Unique advantages:
- Strong regional presence and understanding of Midwest risks
- Excellent reputation among independent agents
- Often provides superior coverage at competitive prices
Considerations:
- Only available through independent agents (not direct)
- Availability varies by location (strong in some Minnesota areas, limited in others)
- Less name recognition than national brands (but excellent actual performance)
Best for:
- Homeowners wanting personalized agent service
- Those preferring regional insurers with local expertise
- Value-conscious consumers who don't want to sacrifice coverage quality
- Properties in suburban and rural Minnesota
Minnesota presence: Available through independent agents, particularly strong in Greater Minnesota
Contact: Find independent agents offering Auto-Owners at auto-owners.com/find-an-agent
4. Chubb (Formerly ACE)
Overall Rating: ★★★★★ (Excellent for High-Value Properties)
Why Chubb excels for high-value pool properties:
Coverage strengths:
- Specializes in high-value homes (typically $750,000+)
- Superior coverage options not available from standard insurers
- Extremely high liability limits ($1M-$100M)
- Agreed value coverage (no depreciation disputes)
- Comprehensive coverage for pool equipment and features
Claims reputation:
- Exceptional claims service
- White-glove treatment during claims
- Fast, generous settlements
- Personal claims representatives assigned to each claim
Customer service:
- Concierge-level service
- Highly knowledgeable agents and underwriters
- Proactive risk management services
- 24/7 premium customer support
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A++
- S&P Rating: AA
- Excellent financial reserves for large claims
Pricing:
- Premium pricing (significantly more expensive than standard insurers)
- Pricing reflects superior coverage and service
- Less price-sensitive customers appreciate value provided
Unique advantages:
- "Masterpiece" policy provides coverage far superior to standard homeowner's policies
- Worldwide coverage for liability
- Extremely high coverage limits
- Superior replacement cost coverage
- Excellent coverage for high-value pool features (infinity edges, custom tile, etc.)
Considerations:
- Only appropriate for high-value homes (typically $750,000+)
- Significantly more expensive than standard insurers
- More stringent underwriting requirements
- May require appraisals and detailed property inspections
Best for:
- High-value homes ($750,000+)
- Custom luxury pools (Plan Pools' premium installations)
- Homeowners with significant assets to protect
- Those prioritizing coverage quality and claims service over price
Minnesota presence: Available through select independent agents specializing in high-value properties
Contact: chubb.com or contact high-value home insurance specialists
5. West Bend Mutual Insurance
Overall Rating: ★★★★ (Excellent for Wisconsin/Minnesota border areas)
Why West Bend excels for pool owners:
Coverage strengths:
- Excellent Midwest regional insurer with strong pool coverage
- Competitive liability limits and umbrella policies
- Reasonable pool-related premium increases
- Good safety feature discounts
- Strong understanding of upper Midwest risks
Claims reputation:
- Excellent claims handling
- High customer satisfaction
- Fair, efficient settlements
- Local adjusters
Customer service:
- Available through independent agents
- Strong customer service
- Good online tools
- Responsive support
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A (Excellent)
- Strong regional presence and financial stability
Pricing:
- Competitive rates
- Good multi-policy discounts
- Fair pricing for pool properties
Unique advantages:
- Strong Midwest regional expertise
- Excellent understanding of freeze-thaw and winter damage issues
- Often provides competitive rates for properties other insurers view as challenging
Considerations:
- Limited availability (primarily Wisconsin, parts of Minnesota and Iowa)
- Less name recognition than national brands
- Available only through independent agents
Best for:
- Properties in western Wisconsin and eastern Minnesota
- Homeowners wanting regional expertise
- Those working with independent agents
- Value-conscious consumers wanting quality coverage
Minnesota presence: Limited to eastern Minnesota and Twin Cities border areas
Contact: westbend.com or find independent agents offering West Bend
Tier 2: Good Pool Coverage (Recommended)
These insurers provide solid coverage and competitive pricing, though may have some limitations:
6. USAA
Overall Rating: ★★★★ (Excellent, but limited availability)
Why USAA excels for eligible members:
Coverage strengths:
- Excellent coverage for military families
- Competitive liability limits
- Good umbrella policy options
- Reasonable pool-related premium increases
- Strong safety feature discounts
Claims reputation:
- Excellent claims handling
- High customer satisfaction ratings
- Fair settlements
- Good communication
Customer service:
- Outstanding customer service ratings
- Excellent mobile app and online tools
- 24/7 availability
- Knowledgeable representatives
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A++
- Excellent financial stability
Pricing:
- Very competitive rates for eligible members
- Excellent bundling discounts
- Good loyalty rewards
Major limitation:
- Only available to military members, veterans, and their families
- Membership eligibility is restricted
Best for:
- Military families
- Veterans and their dependents
- Those already using USAA for other insurance needs
Minnesota presence: Available statewide to eligible members
Contact: usaa.com (must verify military eligibility)
7. American Family Insurance
Overall Rating: ★★★★ (Good)
Why American Family is solid for pool owners:
Coverage strengths:
- Insures pool properties readily
- Adequate liability limits available
- Reasonable umbrella policies
- Fair pool-related premium increases (15-25%)
- Standard safety feature discounts
Claims reputation:
- Generally good claims handling
- Reasonable settlements
- Some variation in customer satisfaction by region
Customer service:
- Local agents throughout Minnesota
- Good online and mobile tools
- Generally responsive customer service
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A (Excellent)
- Solid financial position
Pricing:
- Competitive rates
- Good bundling discounts
- Fair pricing for pool properties
Considerations:
- Claims satisfaction varies more than top-tier insurers
- Some customers report challenges with major claims
- Coverage quality good but not exceptional
Best for:
- Homeowners wanting regional insurer
- Those bundling home and auto
- Properties with standard pools and typical features
Minnesota presence: Strong presence throughout Minnesota with many local agents
Contact: amfam.com or find local agents
8. Liberty Mutual
Overall Rating: ★★★½ (Good)
Why Liberty Mutual is decent for pool owners:
Coverage strengths:
- Insures pool properties
- Adequate liability coverage available
- Umbrella policies available
- Standard pool-related premium increases (18-28%)
Claims reputation:
- Mixed claims experience
- Some customers report excellent service, others report challenges
- Variable by region and claim type
Customer service:
- Available through agents or direct
- Good online tools
- 24/7 customer service
Financial strength:
- A.M. Best Rating: A (Excellent)
- Large national insurer with strong financial position
Pricing:
- Moderately competitive
- Better rates with bundling
- Accident forgiveness and other programs can improve value
Considerations:
- Premium increases can be significant for pool addition
- Claims experience varies significantly
- Customer service quality inconsistent
Best for:
- Those already with Liberty Mutual for auto insurance
- Homeowners wanting national brand recognition
- Bundling multiple policies
Minnesota presence: Available statewide through agents and direct
Contact: libertymutual.com
Tier 3: Adequate Pool Coverage (Acceptable but Shop Around)
These insurers will cover pools but may not provide the best value or service:
9. Allstate
Overall Rating: ★★★ (Adequate)
Why Allstate is acceptable:
Coverage strengths:
- Will insure pool properties
- Adequate liability coverage available
- Umbrella policies available
- Standard coverage options
Claims reputation:
- Highly variable claims experience
- Some customers report excellent service
- Many customers report disputes and low settlements
- Significant variation by agent and location
Pricing:
- Often higher premiums for pool properties (20-35% increases)
- Bundling discounts available but may not offset higher base rates
Considerations:
- Claims satisfaction below top-tier insurers
- Premium increases for pools can be substantial
- Better options usually available at similar or lower prices
Best for:
- Those already with Allstate who receive competitive renewal quotes
- Long-term customers with good loyalty discounts
Minnesota presence: Available statewide through agents
10. Farmers Insurance
Overall Rating: ★★★ (Adequate)
Why Farmers is acceptable:
Coverage strengths:
- Will insure most pool properties
- Standard liability coverage
- Umbrella options available
Claims reputation:
- Mixed customer experiences
- Some areas report good service, others report challenges
Pricing:
- Variable by location
- Pool premium increases can be substantial (20-30%+)
Considerations:
- Very inconsistent experience by agent and location
- Shop carefully and compare quotes
Best for:
- Those receiving competitive quotes
- Specific agents with good local reputations
Minnesota presence: Available statewide through independent agents
Insurance Providers to Approach with Caution
Some insurers commonly create challenges for pool owners:
Companies That Often Don't Cover Pools or Charge Excessive Premiums:
Nationwide:
- Often refuses to insure homes with pools or charges very high premiums
- Significant restrictions on pool types and features
- Better options usually available
Progressive:
- Primarily focused on auto insurance
- Homeowner's coverage often limited or expensive for pool properties
- Better suited for those prioritizing auto insurance
Geico:
- Homeowner's insurance underwritten by various companies
- Pool coverage availability highly variable
- Often not competitive for pool properties
The Hartford:
- Good for certain niche markets (AARP members, etc.)
- Pool coverage can be limited or expensive
- Better options usually available for pool owners under age 50
Strategic Approach: Finding Your Best Insurance Provider
Rather than simply choosing the "best" company from our list, follow this strategic process:
Step 1: Identify Available Providers
Start with 8-10 insurers from our recommended list:
- Your current homeowner's insurance company (if on recommended list)
- 3-4 top-tier providers (State Farm, Travelers, Auto-Owners)
- 2-3 second-tier providers (American Family, USAA if eligible)
- 1-2 companies offering especially competitive quotes
Step 2: Request Detailed Quotes
For each provider, request quotes for:
Homeowner's policy with pool coverage:
- Dwelling coverage including pool value
- Liability coverage at multiple limits ($300K, $500K, $1M)
- Medical payments coverage ($5K-$10K)
- Personal property coverage
- All available safety feature discounts
Umbrella policy:
- $1 million coverage
- $2 million coverage (for comparison)
Bundled pricing:
- Combined home + auto
- Combined home + auto + umbrella
- Multi-policy discounts clearly identified
Step 3: Compare Apples to Apples
Create a comparison spreadsheet:
Provider
Home Premium
Liability Limit
Umbrella Cost
Total Annual Cost
Safety Discounts
Claims Rating
Agent Quality
Don't choose solely on price. Weigh:
- Total cost (home + umbrella)
- Coverage quality and limits
- Claims reputation
- Customer service quality
- Agent accessibility and expertise
- Financial strength
- Your comfort level with the company
Step 4: Verify Coverage Details
For your top 2-3 options, carefully review:
Policy exclusions:
- What pool-related incidents are NOT covered?
- Any concerning gaps or limitations?
Safety requirements:
- Mandatory safety features
- Inspection requirements
- Ongoing obligations
Claims process:
- How to report claims
- Typical response times
- Assignment of adjusters
Policy management:
- Online access and tools
- Mobile app functionality
- Billing and payment options
Step 5: Check Reviews and Reputation
Research each finalist:
Review sources:
- J.D. Power customer satisfaction ratings
- Better Business Bureau complaints and ratings
- Consumer Reports insurance company ratings
- State insurance department complaint ratios
- Online reviews (Google, Yelp, etc.)
Focus on:
- Claims handling experiences
- Customer service quality
- Communication during claims
- Settlement fairness
- Overall satisfaction
Step 6: Consider the Agent Relationship
Especially for companies sold through agents:
Evaluate the specific agent:
- Knowledge about pool insurance
- Responsiveness and availability
- Proactive policy reviews
- Communication style
- Long-term reliability
Agent quality often matters more than company name. An excellent agent with a second-tier company may provide better overall experience than a poor agent with a top-tier company.
Step 7: Make Your Decision
Select based on balanced evaluation:
Weighting factors (suggested):
- Price (30%): Total cost for adequate coverage
- Coverage quality (25%): Limits, exclusions, endorsements
- Claims reputation (20%): How well they handle pool-related claims
- Customer service (15%): Agent quality, accessibility, communication
- Financial strength (10%): Ability to pay large claims
Trust your instincts: If something feels off during the quoting process (pushy sales, unclear answers, concerning exclusions), that's valuable information.
Step 8: Annual Review and Shopping
Don't "set and forget":
Year 1-2:
- Review coverage annually
- Confirm adequate limits as property value changes
- Document any pool improvements or safety features
Year 3:
- Obtain 3-5 competitive quotes
- Compare current coverage and pricing to alternatives
- Consider switching if better value exists elsewhere
Every 3-4 years:
- Comprehensive shopping process
- Full review of coverage needs
- Update liability limits to match asset growth
Special Considerations for Plan Pools Customers
If you're building your pool with Plan Pools, our construction methodology and quality may provide insurance advantages:
ICF Construction Benefits
Our ICF (Insulated Concrete Form) construction creates pools that insurers recognize as superior:
Structural advantages:
- Superior resistance to Minnesota freeze-thaw cycles
- Better soil compaction reducing settling and movement
- Reinforced concrete walls with lifetime structural warranty
Insurance implications:
- Reduced risk of structural failures
- Lower likelihood of claims from pool damage
- May qualify for better rates or terms
Comprehensive Documentation
We provide thorough documentation:
- Detailed construction records
- Permit and inspection reports
- Equipment specifications and warranties
- Maintenance guidelines and recommendations
Value for insurance:
- Simplifies insurance company underwriting
- Supports proper coverage amounts
- Helps substantiate claims if needed
- Demonstrates responsible ownership
Safety Feature Integration
Standard Plan Pools installations include:
- Professional-grade automated safety covers
- Proper fencing meeting Minnesota code requirements
- Quality lighting and visibility features
- Superior equipment reducing malfunction risk
Insurance advantages:
- Qualify for maximum safety discounts
- Demonstrate commitment to risk reduction
- May result in more competitive premium offers
Cost Comparison: What You Should Expect to Pay
Based on Minnesota market data for typical pool properties:
Annual Premium Ranges by Provider Tier
For $400,000 home with $110,000 pool (total insured value: $510,000)
Tier 1 Providers (State Farm, Travelers, Auto-Owners, Chubb):
- Homeowner's policy: $1,650-$2,200 annually
- $1M umbrella: $175-$300 annually
- Total: $1,825-$2,500 annually
Tier 2 Providers (American Family, USAA, Liberty Mutual):
- Homeowner's policy: $1,550-$2,100 annually
- $1M umbrella: $200-$350 annually
- Total: $1,750-$2,450 annually
Tier 3 Providers (Allstate, Farmers):
- Homeowner's policy: $1,700-$2,400 annually
- $1M umbrella: $250-$400 annually
- Total: $1,950-$2,800 annually
Price spread from lowest to highest: $1,750-$2,800 ($1,050 difference)
This demonstrates why shopping multiple providers is worthwhile—potentially saving $500-$1,000+ annually while obtaining equal or better coverage.
Conclusion: Choosing Your Best Pool Insurance Partner
Selecting the right insurance provider for your Minnesota home with a pool requires balancing coverage quality, pricing, service, and long-term relationship potential.
Key takeaways:
Top-tier providers (State Farm, Travelers, Auto-Owners) typically offer the best combination of coverage, pricing, and service for pool owners
Regional specialists often provide excellent value and understanding of Minnesota-specific risks
High-value properties benefit from specialized insurers like Chubb who understand custom pool features
Price matters, but coverage quality and claims handling matter more—don't sacrifice adequate protection to save $100-$200 annually
Agent relationships are crucial—an excellent agent with a second-tier company often provides better experience than a poor agent with a top company
Shop strategically by obtaining multiple quotes every few years while considering total value, not just price
Adequate liability coverage ($500K-$1M minimum) is non-negotiable—umbrella policies provide cost-effective way to reach appropriate levels
Your Partner in Pool Excellence
At Plan Pools, we've guided hundreds of Minnesota families through every aspect of pool ownership, including insurance considerations. Our premium ICF construction creates pools that insurance companies recognize as superior quality, potentially resulting in better coverage terms and pricing.
When you work with Plan Pools, you benefit from:
- Comprehensive documentation that streamlines insurance underwriting
- Superior construction that reduces long-term risk and claims
- Professional guidance on insurance considerations during planning
- Quality installations that meet or exceed all safety requirements
Contact us today to schedule your pool consultation. We'll help you create your backyard oasis while ensuring you're set up for success with proper insurance protection.
Your family's safety and financial security are too important to leave to chance. Choose both the right pool builder and the right insurance provider to ensure years of worry-free swimming enjoyment.
Related Resources: